An Argumentative​ Church: Breaks the Heart of God


I remember it like it was yesterday.  I graduated seminary with this childlike understanding of the work I was called to do. “Go, Teach, and Baptize.”  Sharing Christ with a group of fellow sojourners and those yet to become a part of this collective we call the Church Universal. Idealistically I believed we are all part of the same team, that my fellow pastors and I would be taking on this fight against the forces of the Evil One together.  Maybe I should have paid more attention to the words of James. He is one of my favorite writers. James is a tell it like it is kind of disciple.  No sugar coating things in his letter.  He takes on the church’s issues head-on.  Four lessons start today from this hard-hitting apostle.

The church is supposed to be united.  It is supposed to come together to advance the cause of God. We are called to do all we can to raise godly children to love and serve God and continue the legacy of faith established by a great cloud of witnesses.   The church has been sent on a mission by our Lord and King to share the Light of the Word with our friends and neighbors.

But far too often what the church has become is a place of unrest, internal fighting, envy, jealousy, we have started a different “Me” movement, the “MeFirst” movement.  If someone were to conduct a survey you would find that many believers do not appear to have a common belief. Oh, we may claim to be in accord, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, but our actions, our conflict makes a very different confession.

James peers into his audiences’ heart and soul and sees three things that were holding them back. If we take off the rose-colored glasses we see the same things in our churches.

 Argumentative Spirit (vv. 1–2a)

What is the source of conflict among you? What is the source of your disputes? Don’t they come from your cravings that are at war in your own lives? You long for something you don’t have, so you commit murder. You are jealous for something you can’t get, so you struggle and fight. You don’t have because you don’t ask.

You have to imagine what James saw in the church breaks the heart of God.  He looked at the church and saw a shocking and disturbing thing, a church divided.  I see that same church today.  The church should be united around the truth of God and the mission. The church should be united in worship and service. Sadly, this is not the reality of what the church was that James saw on display.  He saw a divided church. James experienced ongoing hostility, mixed with brief outbursts of antagonism.

What was feeding this quarrelsomeness spirit? People were going to church for the wrong reason.  A “MeFirst” attitude driving their attendance. Members were not there to help the church and advance the mission of Christ, but to advance themselves. Each wanted to be known as somebody. Each was seeking his or her own good instead of the good of brothers and sisters in Christ.

Their lust for notoriety led them to ‘murder’ one another. Things didn’t get to the actual level, but the deep hatred led to inward murder.

Can you imagine being in such a spiritual setting?  Maybe you can.  It is possible you are or were in one and that has turned you off to Christianity.  A church filled with anger and strife lacks the credibility to preach the gospel.  It invalidates its own message. How can you ask those unconnected, disengaged members of society, ‘Come to church and meet a Savior who will change your life’ and see believers behave in such a godless manner? My response would be “no thanks, I see how it has changed you. I will pass.”

Jesus simplified the commandments for us on the night he was betrayed.

34 “I give you a new commandment: Love each other. Just as I have loved you, so you also must love each other. 35 This is how everyone will know that you are my disciples, when you love each other.”John 13

 Next week we pick up the other issue in James chapter four, looking at the absence of a prayer life. And we will conclude this series with the issue of worldliness and what is the pathway back for the church.  Stay tuned.


More on this series on the Book of James:

3 Comments on “An Argumentative​ Church: Breaks the Heart of God

  1. thanks for the post.

    i believe Christians, believers, disciples and those who are born-again who truly love Jesus would want to live in peace with each other.

    those of us who love life and love God, we don’t want to get into a fight for no good ending

    sometimes we get situation of “willful sinner” and leadership that refused to do the right thing for justice, and that result in suppressed anger which can blow up over time.

    for example, just to share one situation when i decided to walk and leave knowing the leadership had created a situation of “pressure cooker” … sure enough that church had been in consistent conflict and resentment among their members

    there was a “member” who had the habit of demanding for VIP service whenever he come to Sunday Service. when he does not get things his way, he bites and push those who refused to show him favor. he even insisted on other to show love and compassion to him as “Christian” but he himself behave like a parasite and blood-sucker!

    one time he was caught in the act. engaging in violent assault against a volunteer Bible teacher who we knew was innocent.

    the incident was investigated, that person himself even admitted what he did. but refused to take responsibility! he even made false accusation the Bible teacher was not nice and polite to him!

    we knew the Senior Pastor kept his silence and refused to do justice for the innocent victim!

    we knew the Senior Pastor refused to do anything for fear of loosing his pay check! we knew that man who did the wrong was a big contributor ($$$$)

    we were very angry the Senior Pastor insisted and impose “because we are Christian we should love him”, and he refused to discipline the man who did wrong! we were talking about a person who habitually hurt people in church! and the leadership let him walk free!

    i left together with those who love God, justice and righteousness.

    the few of us who left, we knew that kind of atmosphere have become unhealthy and poisonous

    we are glad we left and find our fellowship focused on true love in Jesus, and in respect for one another.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Let Your Light So Shine

Tripping Gracefully through Life One Adventure at a Time

Sipping Cups of Inspiration

Sipping Cups of Inspiration Served One Cup at A Time

Pastor Bob

Gathering up life's lessons.

The Annual Bloggers Bash

The Official Website for the Best Blogging Event of the Year!

Positively Confident

"Positively Confident" is more than just a phrase– it is a way of life. A guide to building you.

Through the Scriptures

Daily Reading God's Word

%d bloggers like this: