How To Make a Good First Impression


One of my favorite comments from my seminary training was, “You only get two new changes in the first year of your call, and you are the first change. So you only get one more; choose wisely.” I have found that advice to be Master Yoda-like wisdom, for all those Star Wars fans. As a new shepherd coming into a new setting too much change too soon sends a message to the congregation and not always a good message. It says to them, “Here are all things you have been doing wrong, and lucky you I am have been called by God to fix you.” Listen to the wisdom of Proverbs 14, “Patience leads to abundant understanding, but impatience leads to stupid mistakes.” The temptation will become overwhelming to walk into a new place and make an immediate impact, resist that temptation. Here are some important reasons why:

1. Your changes need to be built on the foundations of relationships.

To be clear, if there are issues of doctrine that is a different matter, but even there you need to take the time to instruct before correction. Here we are thinking about issues of practice and tradition. The things being done have usually developed over a long period of time and have become second nature to the congregation. When you decided to take on that sacred cow, you need to first understand how the sacred cow became sacred. Who instituted the practice and why? Are you unknowingly attacking the ideas of a beloved former pastor or charter member? You don’t often win those fights by the way. However, how you go about addressing the issue is spending time with God’s people in meaningful conversation as you are building lasting relationships, so you develop the assets of trust. When change backfires it is often because people question your motives and don’t know you well enough to trust your actions. In being patient enough to build on the foundation of strong lasting relationships, you earn the right to be trusted and make necessary changes but takes time.

2. Remember to minister to your family.

So often pastors are so excited and eager to get going in their new calling that they tend to forget the emotional changes that the family is going through. As a congregation here is where you can be a huge blessing. This is a great ministry opportunity for the lovely compassionate ladies of the congregation to take the time to build a relationship with the new pastor’s wife and family. Imagine the anxiety the new wife in that new community is experiencing. Wondering if people will like and receive her as a valued member of this long established community. She doesn’t have a history there.  Usually no family connections. It is just her small family unit providing support and a sense of comfort. Wouldn’t be great for the people with the gift of hospitality to take time to intentionally plan ways to make this family feel a part of this community? This is one area I see that determines how long a pastor may stay. If the family never gets integrated into the church’s community, it makes for an unhappy congregation/pastoral marriage.

With all the talk of elections and transitions here are just some thoughts for pastors and congregations to consider. To God be the Glory!



3 Comments on “How To Make a Good First Impression

  1. From Rev. Michael Hanel. I think you hit this one out of the park. Both points are interrelated: relationships are key. Your relationships with your new flock and your relationship with your family. At the Seminary an illustration about how/when to make changes at a church was given using a poker analogy (making a big change is like putting all your chips on the table. if you spend them all in one chance, you’re on a very short chain the rest of the game.) It certainly made the point that you can’t go in and upset the apple cart, but I believe your point is more on target and says exactly what needs to be said.


  2. Pingback: Your First 100 Days as Shepherd – RevKeithHaney

  3. Those relationships are key and those relationships are important in any kind of change.
    Time is needed to understand the congregation and why they do what they do – – even if it is wrong. That doesn’t mean things can’t change, but as the new face, the congregation needs to know you and trust you.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Valuing quiet and solitude in academe.

Kenn's Komments

...random musings from a random guy...

The Minireads

Book reviews and lessons

Disciple Life - Living the MIRACULOUS life: you can have it too!!!

“I tell you the truth, anyone who believes in me will do the same works I have done, and even greater works, because I am going to be with the Father. You can ask for anything in my name, and I will do it, so that the Son can bring glory to the Father. Yes, ask me for anything in my name, and I will do it!" -John. 14:12-14

Lift Him Up

Debra Pedrow: Christian Author and Blogger


Find Your Number

Running with a Friend

Because we are never alone

Its a Beautiful Life

Annette Leeann Flores

Let There Be Light

Ideas of Light that Penetrate the Ideas of Darkness (To read this blog in context, readers should start at the earliest date of a series)

Radical Discipleship

A Joint Project of Bartimaeus Cooperative Ministries and Word & World

%d bloggers like this: